The 5-Minute PRIME podcast from REIPrime.com helps busy professionals master personal finance and real estate investing with quick, actionable tips. Keep learning, stay strategic, and keep building - one smart move at a time!
Your Rental's Lease Ends in December. Renew It for Twelve Months?
•Martin Maxwell•Season 1•Episode 185
Your tenant's lease ends December 31, and the renewal form already says twelve months. Sign it, and next December you're renewing in the middle of winter again.
Twelve months feels like a rule. It's a habit. Spring asking rents do run higher than winter's, but take out the year's normal growth and the gap was about 1.2% nationally over the last three winters, roughly $23 a month on a typical rent. The month that costs you is the empty one.
In this episode of the 5-Minute PRIME Podcast, host Martin Maxwell takes apart the twelve-month default and shows how to use the lease term itself as a lever: which month to aim for, how to price an odd term, and what the tenant gets out of it.
Tune in to learn:
Why the term is a lever — a five-, seven-, seventeen- or eighteen-month renewal moves your next vacancy risk out of winter, unless your unit is rent-regulated or your city sets renewal terms.
What a December lease end really costs — about $23 a month of seasonal rent nationally (it swings more in some metros than others), against close to $2,000 for a single empty month.
How to price the odd term — eighteen months at today's renewal price costs you the next raise, pushed back six months, roughly $320 on a typical rent; a short-term premium has to be tested against the empty month.
The deadlines you can't skip — notice windows and automatic renewal clauses depend on your lease and your state. In New York, a raise of 5% or more on a one-year lease needs at least 60 days' notice.
Do you know what month every one of your leases ends? And does your renewal offer give the tenant a reason to stay past winter?
Subscribe now to set your lease terms on purpose, not by default.
Find your metro at rei.pm/markets and follow it on its market page.
Thank you for tuning in to the 5-Minute PRIME Podcast! Ready for more tips to master personal finance and real estate investing? Visit REIPrime.com for additional resources and strategies to build your wealth. Don’t forget to subscribe, leave a review, and share this episode with someone looking to level up their finances. Follow us on social media for daily updates and more actionable advice!
Welcome to the 5 Minute Prime Podcast. Quick actionable tips to master personal finance and real estate investing. In just five minutes a day, we'll help you build wealth and achieve financial freedom. Hey Prime Investors, Martin Maxwell here. Welcome back to the 5-Minute Prime Podcast.
Your tenant's lease ends December 31st. The renewal form is already filled in. Same tenant, new rent, 12 months. You sign it, send it, and next December you're right back here, renewing the lease in the middle of winter again. 12 months feels like a rule. It isn't. So today, why the length of the lease is a lever you're probably not pulling, what a December lease end really costs you, and how to price an odd term so it pays for itself.
A 12-month lease renewal is a habit, not a rule. The form comes with 12 already typed in, and it's easy to sign it the way it came. But in most places, a lease can run for whatever term you and your tenant agree to in writing. Five months, seven, seventeen, eighteen. The length of the lease decides the month it ends, and the month it ends decides when your next vacancy risk lands. Renew for 12 in December, and that risk lands in December again next year, and the year after that. One exception. If your unit is rent regulated, or your city has its own renewal rules, the term may already be set for you, so check your lease and your state first. Everywhere else, the term is a lever, and it's yours to
set. Now, the folklore says the reason to avoid a winter lease end is that rents drop in winter. That's partly true, and mostly not. Spring asking rents do run higher than winters, but part of that gap is just the year's normal rent growth showing up on the calendar. Take the growth out, and in our monthly rent data across the last three winters, spring ran about 1.2% above winter nationally. On a typical asking rent of about $1,930, that's about $23 a month. That number swings a lot more in some metros than in others, and a write-up on the site maps it out. But nationally, $23 a month is the small number. The big one is a month with no rent coming in. I've made the case before that a turn is about a week of work and the unit sits empty about a month. On that same rent, one empty month is close to $2,000. That's about seven years' worth of the seasonal difference. And one empty month is about 8% of a year's rent on its own, which has to fit inside the half of your rent the 50% rule sets aside for running the place. To be straight with you, I don't have a number for how much longer a unit sits empty in December than in May. Our data doesn't measure it, so I won't hand you a guess. What the Census Bureau's survey does show is the national rental vacancy rate at 7.6% in the third quarter, up from about 6.5% in 2023. A bigger share of rentals is sitting empty than three years ago. And spring asking rents running firmer suggests more renters are outlooking then. How much faster a unit fills in May, we can't measure. So don't bet on the season. Bet on the tenant who stays. So the best outcome on a December lease end is the tenant who stays. There's a line in my book that fits here. Retention beats recruitment. And the term is one of the few retention tools that doesn't cost you a rent cut. We've run the turnover math before on a good tenant asking for $300 off to renew, and the best move there wasn't a cut
either. So what's an odd term worth? Pricing an odd lease term comes down to one comparison. Say the typical asking rent nationally, about $1,930 a month as of September, and a raise of 2.7%, about what asking rents rose over the past year. That puts the renewal near $1984 a month. Offer 18 months at that price instead of $12, and what it costs you, if the tenant would have renewed again anyway, is the next raise pushed back six months, roughly $320. A five-month term can carry a short-term premium. Test any premium against one number, an empty month, about $2,000 on that rent. If a $50 premium sends the tenant looking elsewhere, you traded $250 for a $2,000 risk. Price the odd term against the empty month, not against the 12-month habit. Five months takes a lease that ends in December to the end of May. 7 takes it to the end of July. 17 or 18 lands it in late spring or early summer of the year after next. Pick the month you'd rather face a turnover in, and work back to the term. If you own more than one door, it matters twice. Three leases that all end in December are three chances to sit empty in the same month. Spread them out, one renewal at a time. Now the tenant side, because they have to say yes. A tenant with kids in school may not want to move in the middle of the school year. A tenant who might change jobs wants the short term and may pay a little for it. A tenant who plans to stay wants the long term, because it holds the price. So put two offers on the table, side by side, and let them pick. If they'd rather have 12 months, 12 is a fine answer. The point is that you chose it. And whatever you offer, offer the same choices to every tenant whose lease is coming up. That's fair to them, and it keeps you on the right side of fair housing rules.
Last piece, and it's the one with a deadline. Notice windows and automatic renewal clauses depend on your lease and your state. In New York, for example, a landlord who wants to raise the rent 5% or more, or not renew, owes a tenant on a one-year lease at least 60 days' notice, and 90 if they've lived there more than two years. For a lease ending December 31st, 60 days back is November 1st. And in New York and Wisconsin, an automatic renewal clause can't be enforced against the tenant unless the landlord sends a written reminder 15 to 30 days before the tenant's own notice deadline. So if a lease of yours ends in December, read it tonight and check your state's rules before you send anything. And if you're in New York, planning a raise of 5% or more and that November date already passed, don't guess. Talk to a local attorney before you send the offer.
So here's your challenge for tonight. Pull every lease you own, and next to each one, write the month it ends. Circle any that end December through February. For each circled lease, look up two things: the notice deadline in your lease and your state, and whether it has an automatic renewal clause. Then what? Before that deadline, write two offers for each circled lease. 12 months at your renewal price and 17 or 18 months at the same price. Next to the longer one, write what it costs you, the next raise pushed back a few months. Send both and let the tenant choose. And if every lease you own ends in the same month, use this renewal to move one of them. 12 months is the default. The month your lease ends is a choice. I'm Martin Maxwell. This has been the Five Minute Prime Podcast. I'll see you next episode.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.