The 5-Minute PRIME podcast from REIPrime.com helps busy professionals master personal finance and real estate investing with quick, actionable tips. Keep learning, stay strategic, and keep building - one smart move at a time!
Your Tenant Can't Live There for Three Weeks. Whose Insurance Pays?
•Martin Maxwell•Season 1•Episode 186
A supply line splits inside the outside wall of your upper unit's kitchen the morning after Christmas. Your restoration contractor says twenty-one nights before anyone can live there, and your tenant of three years texts: your pipe, your hotel. An extended-stay at $125 a night is $2,625.
In this episode of the 5-Minute PRIME Podcast, host Martin Maxwell sorts the four bills a burst pipe sends you, shows which policy pays each one, and runs the empty weeks through the cash flow math for the option that looks cleanest.
Tune in to learn:
Fair rental value vs. loss of use — the line in your policy that pays your lost rent, and the line in his that pays his room.
Why stopping the rent isn't generosity — what Minnesota law says about a home made unfit through no fault of the tenant, and what happens to rent once a city declares a unit unfit.
The clock you control — both policies pay "for the shortest time required to repair," so the dry-out schedule is your claim.
When the tenant has no renters policy — who pays the room, and how to help without opening a tab.
Do you know whether your landlord policy carries fair rental value coverage, and what its limit is? And do you have proof that each of your tenants carries renters insurance right now?
Policy wording differs by insurer and form; landlord-tenant rules vary by state and city. Framing, not legal or insurance advice.
Subscribe now to know which policy owes which bill before the first cold snap.
Find your metro at rei.pm/markets and follow it on its market page.
Thank you for tuning in to the 5-Minute PRIME Podcast! Ready for more tips to master personal finance and real estate investing? Visit REIPrime.com for additional resources and strategies to build your wealth. Don’t forget to subscribe, leave a review, and share this episode with someone looking to level up their finances. Follow us on social media for daily updates and more actionable advice!
Welcome to the 5 Minute Prime Podcast. Quick actionable tips to master personal finance and real estate investing. In just five minutes a day, we'll help you build wealth and achieve financial freedom. Hey Prime Investors, Martin Maxwell here. Welcome back to the 5-Minute Prime Podcast.
Say it's 6 40 in the morning, the day after Christmas, and your phone is buzzing. It's your upstairs tenant, and there's water coming out of the kitchen wall. By noon, you'll have a flooded unit, a three-week repair schedule, and a text that reads, Your pipe, your hotel. Here's the building. An up and down duplex in Minneapolis. The upper unit rents for $17.36 a month, which is the typical asking rent across the Minneapolis Metro this September. Call it about $57 a day. Same tenant for three years, never once late. Your insurance is a landlord policy on the dwelling special form, with a $1,000 deductible and a line called fair rental value. Hold on to that phrase. That policy covers your building and your rent. It doesn't cover his couch and it doesn't cover where he sleeps. And his lease says he has to carry renter's insurance. Did you ever collect the proof? If you didn't, you're in very large company. And the day after Christmas is not the day to beat yourself up about it.
So, the night before, it hit something like 20 below. His heat was on, 68 degrees. Didn't matter. A supply line inside the outside wall of the kitchen split. You talk him to the main shutoff over the phone, but the water's already through the floor and running down the wall. Your restoration contractor sends a written schedule. Open the walls, three or four days of drying, then rebuild. 21 nights before anyone can live up there. He's found an extended stay hotel at $125 a night. 21 nights. 2625. On your card.
So, three options. Pick yours before I tell you mine. Option one, stop the rent today and send every bill to the insurance policy that owes it. Option two, pay the hotel yourself. 2625 keeps a tenant who's never been late, and the argument ends this afternoon. Option three, let him out of the lease. Mutual. In writing. Refund the December days and his deposit, and re-rent the unit once it's rebuilt. Three options. Hit pause, decide, then come back.
Before any of the three, do one thing. Sort the bills. A burst pipe sends you four of them, and they don't all belong to you. Bill 1. Opening the walls, drying, rebuilding. That's your dwelling coverage after your $1,000 deductible. Bill 2, the rent. 21 days is about $1,200. That's what fair rental value is for. It's the part of your landlord policy that pays you the rent a covered loss costs you. Bill three, the hotel. That's his renter's policy, a line called loss of use. It pays the increase in his living costs. So the room minus what he'd normally spend. With his rent stopped, his insurer covers about $14.30, and the $1,200 he isn't paying you goes toward the room. Bill 4. His couch, his clothes, his laptop. His renter's policy again. Line those up, and the only money out of your own pocket is the deductible. And on the standard form, that deductible comes off the claim once, not once per bill. We've talked before about getting insurance into the deal math before you buy. This is the other half of that. Knowing what the policy actually pays after you own the place, before the phone rings at 640.
So option one. And stopping the rent here isn't you being generous. Minnesota law promises a home fit to live in, and a court can cut the rent while it isn't. If a home becomes unfit to live in through no fault of the tenant, he can move out and hand it back. And if the city declares the unit unfit, any rent you take after that can cost you three times over. Rules vary by state. That's Minnesota. Now here's the phrase in your policy that matters most. Fair rental value pays for the shortest time required to repair. His loss of use is worded the same way. Which means the speed of the dryout is your job. Water off. Accru there the same day. Walls open and drying inside 24 to 48 hours. That's the EPA's window for keeping mold out. Fans, dehumidifiers, moisture readings logged every day and every receipt kept. The policy itself asks you to protect the property from further damage and keep a record of what the repairs cost. And when the adjuster writes 14 days and your contractor's schedule says 21? We've talked before about how a number the other side produces isn't a receipt. The adjuster's estimate is the insurer's number. Send the written schedule and the moisture readings before you agree to anything. Seven days is about $400 of rent. Option two is the kind one, and the poll makes sense. But your policy doesn't pay a tenant's hotel. So that $2625 is yours, spent on a bill his premium was supposed to cover. If he has a renter's policy, you just paid his insurer's bill for them. If he doesn't, you made a gift. A gift can be the right call. It just shouldn't be the default you slide into because the text said your pipe. Option 3 looks clean. It isn't. It trades insured weeks for uninsured ones. Fair rental value stops when the repair is done, and the standard form doesn't cover loss from canceling a lease. Say you re-rent on March 1st. The weeks after January 16th run about $2,500, plus turnover, and nobody pays you back. Put the duplex into the deal analyzer on the site with a month of rent missing and watch what it does to your year. And he can already leave under Minnesota law if he wants to. There's no reason to push a tenant who's paid on time for three years. Now the hard version. What if he doesn't have renter's insurance? Then the room is his. He's not paying rent, so it costs him about $14.30 more than three normal weeks. The rent you stopped is what you owe him. Anything past that is your choice. If you want to help, and with a three-year tenant you might, write it down as a one-time amount, not an open tab. And at the next renewal, the renter's insurance clause stops being paperwork nobody checks. You collect the declarations page at signing, the same way you collect the deposit. Two things would change this answer. The first is the cause. The standard policy forms only cover a frozen pipe if the policyholder took reasonable care to keep the heat on or drain the water. Heat on at 68 is the reasonable care the form asks for. If he'd shut his furnace off and left town for the holidays, your claim gets harder, and an insurer that pays could go after him. That's subrogation. The second is the city. If Minneapolis condemns the unit and ties it to the building's upkeep, its relocation ordinance can require you to pay his relocation. That's the day you call a landlord tenant attorney, not the day after. The book makes a point about the insurance agent that fits right here. Landlord policies aren't homeowner policies, so you want an agent who works with investors. It's why the Core V, the team you build before you buy, has one in it. The pipe was yours. The room never was.
Here's your challenge. Tonight, pull up your declarations page and find the line that says fair rental value or loss of rents. Write down the limit. If it isn't there, call your insurance agent this week, before the first cold snap, not after it. Then message every tenant one line. Please send your renter's insurance declarations page by Friday. If someone doesn't have a policy, that's your next lease conversation, not your next emergency. The full write up, all three options side by side with the bill by bill table is linked in the show notes. I'm Martin Maxwell. This has been the Five Minute Prime Podcast. I'll see you next episode.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.